субота, 3 жовтня 2009 р.

Crazy India

Not dangerous, not incredible, not scary, not beautiful – I would like to call my first post about this country exactly like that. After a bit more than 1 month of staying here I can describe India only with the word crazy! I thought that after some time this feeling will disappear. But each new day gives more reasons to think that I am in crazy country, people are crazy here and I am crazy because I came here and frankly speaking I love this feeling! ;)

Few things that I think of India after 1 month:

1. India is completely different from what I’ve read and heard about it. Before coming to India I was preparing a lot. I’ve read dozens of websites, blogs, articles about India, way of life there and how is that to be a foreigner in this country. Honestly speaking after doing that I started to have doubts whether I made a right decision about choosing that country and if I’ll be able to survive for 6 months here. ‘Lonely Planet’ has 30 pages that are describing only all dangerous situations that can happen to white women in India!!!! Seriously it’s not that bad! I am walking streets alone, I am drinking water, I don’t clean plates with soap before eating in the restaurants, I eat in the streets, I talk with local people and nothing bad happened to me! Of course I am not saying that it’s very safe. As well as you cannot say that about US, Ukraine or any other country.

2. India is very different, but it doesn’t mean that it is worse than any other country. In the first days of my stay here I was pissed off with so many things. Trash on the streets, uncontrolled traffic, streets full with pissing people – list can be very long. I thought all those things are happening because of poverty and uneducated people. Partly it’s true, but that’s o nly one side of the coin. Recently I had a conversation with my manager at work – very intelligent, smart and nice person. He told me that some time ago he received very attractive job offer in USA. And he rejected it because he couldn’t imagine his life in the country where he would be able to piss only in public toilets and throw away garbage only to trash bins… He told me that in India he feels free and he can’t live in the county where he will have to follow so many rules as in US! After that conversation I thought that very often “western people” think that their way of life is right for everybody, everything that is different seems worse to us. ‘Right’ for us can be completely ‘wrong’ to Indians and if I am in this country I have to accept their way of life as probably they know better than me what is ‘right’ for them.

3. Indians are happy! This is the thing I admire most here. If you walk the street in Delhi or any other Indian city you’ll see poverty and miserable life conditions. I don’t consider Ukraine as developed country but never in my life have I seen so much poverty as here although in Ukraine we have lots of it. At the sa me you look around and you see people smiling to each other, talking and laughing. I know so many Ukrainians who feel upset because they don’t have most modern phone or TV or they live in small apartment. And I think about hun dreds of Indians which I see everyday sleeping on the street who seem like enjoy their life much more! That’s definitely one of the things that we should learn from these incredible people.

4. Сonservatism. Honestly speaking there are lots of things which I admire about India and people here, but there’s one thing I hate – castes. Caste system describes the social stratification and social restrictions in India. And it’s not even coming from India. Castes appeared when Aryans invaded India. Aryans entered India from the Northwest and established a caste system, in which they placed themselves primarily in higher castes. Aborigines were placed to lower castes. Basically, the whiter your skin is the higher caste you have. And after thousands of years they still obey and believe in this completely unfair system. In big cities it’s not as strong as in rural areas. But even in Delhi there are people that belong to so called ‘untouchable caste’. ‘Untouchables’ are the people that are not allowed to do any other work except of throwing away garbage. It’s considered bad in Indian society to touch those people as they are ‘dirty’. And this is 21% of Indian population as per 2001 Census!!! And the worse thing is that majority of people feel comfortable about that, and so far it doesn’t look like that it’s going to change soon.

5. AIESEC in India. After 5 years of being AIESEC member I feel really attached to this organization in any country. At the same time there are AIESEC countries which I really love and admire. This is of course AIESEC Ukraine and without any doubts AIESEC India. During my MC term I was lucky to work close with AIESECers from India, I’ve run dozens of sessions to Ukrainian AIESECers des cribing great work style and commitment that Indians have. I did enjoy communication and work with Indians and I value a lot friendship that I’ve made with people in AIESEC India. Because of that I now feel very confused with things that I am facing everyday here. When I just arrived to trainees house in Delhi I’ve met near 10 interns who were living there. Approximately after 1 day of my stay there I was told all bad stories that happened to trainees because of AIESECers, about all the people that were not met in the airport, all undelivered promises and I was advised from the first day not to count on AIESEC here. Now after 1 month in India I even cannot remember how many complaints from different people I’ve heard. And the worst thing is it looks like it will last forever. Because when new interns are coming from the 1st day they get bad impression of AIESEC here even they didn’t have any bad experience with AIESEC by themselves. I also got a feeling that this kind of relationships between AIESEC and trainees became normal for lots of AIESECers here and they stopped trying to improve that. In the beginning I was all the time arguing with interns saying that they exaggerate everything and they should try to change situation by themselves, being more proactive and tolerant. But now I feel that people here were so many times disappointed with AIESEC that they just don’t believe that something might change and that’s why they prefer not to interact with AIESECers at all. I was thinking a lot about this situation and it really bothers me. By no mean i want to say that AIESEC in India is bad and that they should stop doing hundreds exchanges and focus only on interns servicing. But I want to tell to every AIESECer – don’t forget that u are bringing human beings here, and they are not furniture that you can just meet in the airport, bring to the house and forget about it. They are the people who make AIESEC incredible organization which all of us love so much. After all I do believe that AIESEC in India is the best entity in the network and I am happy that I am part of it right now. I just think that because of intensity of their work and pressure that these young people feel everyday they sometimes loose the focus and forget why they joined this organization. I know that it’s easy to say but much more difficult to change that. At the same time I feel that Indians can do whatever but only if they want. Well, I wish them good luck!..

That’s it for now! Will try to be shorter next time ;)

9 коментарів:

  1. Thanks Lara for sharing! Really interesting to read ur opinion and thoughts. Write more and the bigger post is the better =)hugs

    ВідповістиВидалити
  2. Finally;)
    i was surprised to know that 21% are untouchables.
    i strongly disagree with what your boss said.
    to me freedom is not about being able to pee in the main street, so that all other people feel like vomiting because of odor his urina creates with 40C temp. Your freedom finished where starts freedom of another person. When your managers feels free to pee in the street i am going through - he is violating my freedom and my rights. This is something this dude could have learned if he visited US for some time.

    ВідповістиВидалити
  3. Hey, nice to read your blog, and see cultural shocks and your toughts about cultural diversity. I agree with you that they have their culture and we should respect this, just as me here in Ukraine, many things I am facing and for sure in Brazil we would criticize and not tolerate at all, but I do respect and learn how to live with this, this is part of the experience! Hope all people could think and feel the same not only AIESECers... Culture as the own name says is something different! It doesn´t make sense to try to push our culture for others!
    Well, regarding trainees complain there, I understand usually is a matter of just criticising and not trying to change, in my first LC in Brazil we had the same problem, even If we had a very good reception and first impression after going to trainees house they heard lot of complains about @ and If it was now AIESECer, they had their mind changed, hope you can contribute somehow for the trainees complain over there and show that this is part of XP, AIESEC is made of volunteers which are there to learn and develop, so they can not have the expectation to receive professional service!

    ВідповістиВидалити
  4. Dear, great post! Nice to hear you like your experiece and learn a lot from it! I'm sure with such posts we also will learn a lot from you!
    Keep writing!
    Olya

    ВідповістиВидалити
  5. Ooooohhhh!!!
    I misss this smiled faces on the street very much. We (Ukrainians) should learn how to be happy and easygoing from Indian.
    Lara, really jealous you and wish you enjoy every minute being there)))))))

    ВідповістиВидалити
  6. I still remember 33 types of smell that I experienced in India few years ago :) It is a beautiful, unbearably dirty country, with its own culture and history. I'm glad you are going through quite a culture exposure. You will always treasure the best of what you've seen there and these small things will make up your memories of India for years and years to come. Enjoy it to the last moment! Exchange RULEZ :)

    ВідповістиВидалити
  7. Agree with Sveta about freedom. Peeing and throwing garbage are not indications at all! about AIESEC in India - it's, unfortunately, a know fact which won't change soon as people won't stop peeing tomorrow. Hopefully some time it will.

    Great things about India - after spending quite a few hours in the toilet there, I started to like and enjoy spicy food;)

    ВідповістиВидалити
  8. Well, Indians pee on the streets, Ukrainians smoke in public places which is forbidden in India. So who after all violates freedom and health of other people more? Though we are considered as more developed country..but are we?

    ВідповістиВидалити
  9. developed country is a very wide definition that has nothing to do with peeing or smoking.It has more economic connotation.
    I am not sure Ukraine or India meet that definition. As for civilized country - this is also questionable. But i agree that Ukraine is not good base for comparison

    ВідповістиВидалити